The Hardest Part of EMDR Is Doing Nothing

If your therapist has suggested EMDR, you may remember the moment they first said the letters, and the small nod you gave, as if you'd heard of it. Then came the explanation: you think about something painful while your attention is pulled back and forth, maybe by following a hand with your eyes, maybe by holding two small paddles that buzz in one palm and then the other. For a lot of people, that raises more questions than it answers. It can sound too simple to work, or too strange to trust, or both.

Most of us start EMDR with two questions, whether or not we say them out loud. How is a buzzing paddle, or a moving hand, supposed to fix anything? And, a little quieter: what if I do it wrong? Both are good questions, and neither one means you're not ready. The first has a real answer. The second has better news than you'd expect, because EMDR is among the few things in life that work better the less you try.

What it is

EMDR stands for Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, a lot of syllables for a simple idea: you hold something painful in mind while your attention is pulled back and forth, and your brain uses the opening to finish a job it left undone. The eye movements gave it the name, but the back-and-forth can come through your hands or your ears just as well. Francine Shapiro developed it in the late 1980s after noticing on a walk that her own upsetting thoughts lost some of their sting when her eyes moved side to side. It sounded too simple to be real, and for a while the field said so. Then it kept working. The World Health Organization and the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs now recommend it for post-traumatic stress, and therapists also use it for anxiety, phobias, grief, and memories that never quite settled.

It isn't hypnosis. You stay awake, aware, and in charge of whether to keep going. You won't be asked to tell the whole story out loud or relive anything for an hour; your therapist mostly needs a sentence or two about what you're noticing. You don't need a dramatic story to qualify, or a clear memory. A single event, years of small things that never seemed big enough to count, a feeling you can't trace to anything yet. EMDR works with all of them.

What your brain was trying to do

Most of the time, our brains digest experience the way our stomachs digest dinner. Something hard happens, we feel it, we make some sense of it, and it gets filed as part of the past. We can still remember it. But it's over, and it knows it's over.

An overwhelming experience can jam that process. Under heavy stress, the brain's alarm system, a small part called the amygdala, can stamp the moment as urgent, while the part that files memories with a time and a place, the hippocampus, can fall behind. The memory can get stored with its original feelings, body sensations, and beliefs still attached, and without the label that says this is finished. If you've ever understood perfectly well that something was in the past while your body reacted as if it were happening in the kitchen, that is what it feels like from the inside.

A stuck memory doesn't know how the story ended.

That is also why knowing better doesn't always fix it. A client of mine, Dana, could recite every reason the thing with her sister wasn't her fault. She had a list. The list lived in one part of her brain and the memory lived in another, and the two had never been introduced.

So how does a moving hand introduce them? Researchers are still mapping the route, but two mechanisms have good support. The first is that your attention is a small room. Hold a painful image in mind while following a moving hand and the image gets dimmer and less upsetting, and some of that change lasts after the hand stops; lab studies have shown this since the 1990s. Your brain can't give a memory its full attention and track a target at the same time, and EMDR puts that limit to work. If the memory blurs or drifts in the middle of a round of eye movements, that's usually the method doing its job, not a lapse on your part. The second is that the alarm gets turned down. In 2018, a Dutch team led by Lycia de Voogd used brain scans to show that guided eye movements quieted the amygdala for a while, and that a fear learned in the lab was less likely to come back the next day when eye movements followed it. Those were healthy volunteers, not anyone's history, but the mechanism is real.

None of this needs you to be clever. Your brain does the work. Your job, mostly, is to stop helping.

Packing before the hike

In a client’s experience, EMDR has two general stages: getting ready, and processing. People are often surprised by how much of the first there is. I've had clients ask, politely, after a few preparation sessions, when the real therapy starts. It already had.

Getting ready starts with your therapist learning your history and the two of you deciding what to work on. Then comes something clinicians call resourcing, a bureaucratic word for a kind thing: building up your ability to stay steady before you go anywhere near the hard material. Think of it as packing your gear before the hike. You'll practice a calm place where your body can settle, a container where you can set distressing material aside between sessions, and simple ways back to the room, like noticing your feet on the floor. You'll agree on a stop signal you can use at any moment. Resourcing widens how much feeling you can hold without being swept off your feet, and it gives you a reliable road back to calm. The people who get the most out of processing are rarely the ones who hurried into it.

How long this takes depends on your history: a session or two for some, much longer for people with long or tangled histories. Sometimes a therapist will hold off on processing for other reasons, like a crisis in progress or a situation that still isn't safe. If that happens to you, hear it the way it's meant. It's a decision about timing, and it says nothing about you or about whether EMDR can help you.

A few practical things help, too. Don't book a processing session right before something demanding, and leave yourself a quiet hour afterward. If the eye movements strain your eyes, say so; paddles or tones work as well. If you do EMDR by video, find a private spot and keep the screen still. And practice your calm place on ordinary days. It's much easier to find when it's familiar.

What happens in the chair

Processing starts with choosing a target, usually a memory or a situation. Your therapist asks you to notice a picture that stands for it, the belief about yourself that comes with it (I'm powerless, I'm not enough), the belief you'd rather hold, the feelings, where you feel them in your body, and how strong it all is on a simple number scale. Don't worry about getting these right. They're a starting point, not a test.

Then the sets. A set is a short stretch, usually under a minute, where you follow your therapist's hand with your eyes, or hold the paddles as they buzz, or listen to tones that move from ear to ear. Your therapist says something like, "Just notice." Then, "What do you notice now?" You say a sentence or two. You go again. Over one session or several, the distress usually comes down and the kinder belief starts to feel true, rather than only sounding true. Every session ends with your therapist helping you settle before you leave, whether or not the memory feels finished.

Trust the Process, Let Go, and Be Open

Which brings us back to the second question, the one about doing it wrong.

Clients ask me, often, how to do EMDR well. The honest-to-God answer is that the harder you try to do it well, the more you get in its way. I understand the urge. I've spent a career wanting to help, and in this chair the most useful thing I do, most of the time, is move my hand and keep my mouth shut. Everything I've watched from that seat comes down to three things, and you can start practicing all three before your first set.

Trust the Process. Your brain has a built-in capacity to finish what it left undone, and your job is mostly to let it. That takes some trust in your therapist, and trust doesn't have to come pre-installed. Use the getting-ready stage to find out whether your therapist goes at your pace and takes your hesitation seriously, and if trust is hard, say so. Saying so often builds the very trust you're worried you don't have. It also takes enough trust in the method to stay with it when it feels strange. Some sets seem to do nothing. Distress sometimes rises before it falls. Skepticism is fine. You don't have to believe in EMDR for it to work. You only have to let it run.

Let Go. During a set, resist the urge to steer. Don't hold the memory still, don't push it toward a resolution, don't try to work out what it means. If it blurs or gets replaced by something unrelated, let it. When your therapist asks what you notice, report what's there, even if it's small or silly. A tight jaw. A song. What you're making for dinner. There's no wrong answer, and "nothing" counts. If you catch yourself trying hard at not trying, that counts too. Say it out loud and go again. You're in charge of whether it continues. You're not in charge of where it goes.

Be Open. Letting go doesn't mean checking out. Being open in EMDR is an active kind of attention: you watch what happens the way you'd watch scenery from a train window, curious about what comes next, without trying to change the view and without looking away. A thought comes, and you notice it. A feeling rises, and you let it be as big as it is. A memory from third grade shows up in the middle of last month's argument, and instead of dismissing it, you let it stay long enough to see what it's doing there.

That same attention goes to your body, to the tightness in your chest or the odd calm that arrives from nowhere, and to the room, because the aim is one foot in the memory and one foot here. If you start to feel foggy, numb, or far away, that's the moment to say so, and it's no failure of openness. And stay open about what progress looks like. It's rarely a lightning bolt. Many people notice it later, in ordinary life. Sometimes the evidence is the flinch that never came.

You can practice this tonight. Sit for two minutes and notice three things in your body without changing any of them. That's the whole skill.

Between sessions, processing often keeps going. You may dream vividly or feel more tender or tired for a day or two. That's common and doesn't mean anything went wrong. Jot down what you notice and bring it to your next session. If anything feels like more than you can carry, contact your therapist, or call or text 988.

Dana, the client with the list, stopped me forty seconds into her first set to apologize. She'd lost the memory, she said. She'd been thinking about dinner. Could we start over, and she'd concentrate this time. We didn't start over. I told her dinner counted, and we went again. Somewhere in the fourth set, she said, "Huh. It's further away." Then she laughed and said, "I didn't do anything."

She was wrong about that. She'd done the hardest part. She'd stopped steering, and she'd kept watching.

Next
Next

Inside Trump’s Mind—and Why It Matters To Us